The Tesla Inc. (NASDAQ:TSLA) and Space Exploration Technologies Corp (NASDAQ:SPCX) merger changes the equity narrative toward the potential acquisition price, HSBC analyst Michael Tyndall said in a note on Friday. He wrote that the strategic logic of a merger is not immediately apparent and that he assumes control is the motive.
Tyndall upgraded Tesla to Hold from Reduce and raised his price forecast to $359 from $157. He kept a Hold rating and a $150 price forecast on SpaceX.
• SpaceX shares are retreating from recent levels. What’s behind SPCX decline?
Merger Talks
On SpaceX’s third-quarter earnings call on Oct. 20, CEO Elon Musk spoke of working committees looking at a merger with Tesla, though he gave no indication of the timeline, the analyst noted. HSBC also cited an unconfirmed Nov. 12 Bloomberg report that a deal could be announced as early as December.
Control, Not Synergies
Tyndall said the two businesses face different and varied customers, which limits the case for combining them. He said the shared need for memory in AI, data centers and large language models makes more sense as a reason. But that need is arguably covered by Terafab, the companies’ chip design and manufacturing joint venture.
“We see control as the key motivation for a merger, especially as CEO Musk has been clear in the past about his need for oversight,” Tyndall wrote.
Musk owns 39% of SpaceX and about 20% of Tesla. SpaceX has two classes of stock. Its Class B stock, which is largely held by Musk, carries 10 votes for each vote carried by Class A stock, so Musk’s 39% stake gives him 70% of the votes. Based on this, Tyndall explored a scenario in which SpaceX acquires Tesla.
He applied a 33% premium, in line with recent similar deals, to Tesla’s 30-day average stock price. That gives an implied acquisition value of $507 for Tesla stock. In the combined company, Musk’s stake would fall to about 60%, the note said.
Capital Needs Favor SpaceX
Tyndall said both companies are consuming cash faster than they generate it. He noted, hypothetically, that if SpaceX and Tesla were both looking to fund free cash flow shortfalls through capital raises, adding Tesla could benefit SpaceX, as the automaker has lower capital expenditure requirements than the rocket company.
HSBC estimates SpaceX holders would gain 2.1% to 11.1% in future dilution savings, while Tesla holders would gain the 33% premium.
New Valuation Method
Tyndall previously valued Tesla using a discounted cash flow (DCF) model, which estimates value from projected future cash flows, together with peer comparisons. With a merger now possible, he said a potential acquisition value is more relevant than peer valuations. He now weights DCF and the $507 acquisition value equally. His DCF fair value is $212.
Musk has said winning approval from 50% of Tesla shareholders “is quite a high hurdle,” the note said.
The new target implies 6% downside. Tyndall said the merger topic is likely to dominate discussion, so he sees limited further downside from current levels.
TSLA, SPCX Price Actions: Tesla shares fell 6.27% to $350.94, while SpaceX shares declined 6.59% to $129.31 at the time of publication Friday, according to Benzinga Pro data.
Image via Shutterstock
See More:
Top Momentum Stocks
Recent Comments