Investor Gary Black of The Future Fund LLC reiterated criticism of a possible Space Exploration Technologies Corp. (NASDAQ:SPCX) and Tesla Inc. (NASDAQ:TSLA) merger.

MRVL-LITE Deal Resulted in Dilution

In a post on the social media platform X, Black pointed to the deal between Lumentum Holdings Inc. (NASDAQ:LITE) and Marvell Technology Inc. (NASDAQ:MRVL) as a “prime example of what can go wrong when a company uses its own stock to buy another company’s stock,” pointing to talks of a possible stock-for-stock deal between SpaceX and Tesla.

“In just over a month, $MRVL’s stock has dropped by -45%, which has cut the +24% premium being paid for $LITE to a -41% discount vs $LITE’s stock price before the announcement,” the investor said. “This occurs because of massive dilution to the acquiring company’s stock.”

He added that the same was “likely” to happen when SpaceX “offers a +24% premium for $TSLA using SPCX stock as currency.” The investor shared that Tesla shareholders “will get a short-term pop on the deal headline and then experience quick downward pressure on $TSLA stock as investors sell $SPCX to try to lock in profits.”

Black opined that Lumentum investors would “love to roll back the clock to Oct 28 when their stock was trading at $914 before MRVL’s offer to pay a +24% premium.”

The investor said, “TSLA at $374 today plus a +24% premium paid in SPCX shares (on paper worth $464/share) could be worth -25% less within a month ($280/share) given what could amount to 50% dilution to $SPCX.”

Elon Musk Reignites Merger Speculation

The comments come as Musk, during an appearance at the Dealbook Summit on Wednesday, fueled speculation of a possible SpaceX-Tesla merger.

“There are so many areas of convergence that didn’t exist in years before and are increasingly significant to the future,” Musk said. “You don’t need them to be together, but would they be better together? I mean, probably, yes,” the Tesla CEO said.

Price Action: SPCX shares were down 2.12% to $135.50 during overnight trading on Thursday, while TSLA was down 1.11% to $370.24 during overnight trading, according to Benzinga Pro data.

Check out more of Benzinga’s Future of Mobility coverage by following this link.

Image via Shutterstock