Sen. Rick Scott (R-Fla.) argued that the U.S. cannot tax its way out of Social Security’s funding problems, saying job creation and economic growth are necessary to preserve benefits.
Scott made the case in an X post accompanying a video of his exchange with Jason J. Fichtner, executive director of the LIMRA Retirement Income Institute, at Wednesday’s Senate Budget Committee hearing.
Scott wrote that taking all the assets of every American billionaire would delay Social Security’s insolvency by only about a decade. He also pointed to 39 million working-age Americans who are not working and said bringing them into the workforce is the way forward.
Scott Challenges Billionaire Tax Proposal
During the hearing, Scott asked Fichtner how much could be raised by liquidating the entire net worth of the Forbes 400, including property, companies and stock holdings. Fichtner estimated the wealth at about $8 trillion and said taking all of it could fill Social Security’s funding gap for roughly 10 years, but would not fix the program’s structural problems.
Fichtner warned that liquidating billionaire wealth could discourage investment and make people fear the government would eventually target more than billionaires and millionaires. He said it could mean fewer companies, jobs, economic growth and tax revenues. He also cautioned that selling large amounts of stock could trigger a market sell-off, lowering the value of 401(k)s, 403(b)s, pensions and other retirement savings, including money invested through the federal Thrift Savings Plan, a retirement plan similar to a private-sector 401(k).
Fichtner also raised the question of whether Social Security surpluses, if they return, should be invested differently. He estimated that the $8 trillion could cover about four years of federal deficits, while warning that higher interest rates could make budget projections less reliable. Fichtner said bringing more people into work would increase payroll tax receipts for Social Security and income tax revenue for the government.
Scott concluded that lawmakers needed a plan, but said, “the only way out of this is you’ve got to grow the economy.”
Johnson Clarifies His Social Security Stance
The hearing also revisited comments by Senate Budget Committee Chair Ron Johnson (R-Wis.), who had called Social Security a “Ponzi scheme” and said it should be shut down during a Fox Business appearance. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) challenged Johnson during the hearing, saying lawmakers should work to fix the program. Johnson called his earlier wording “imprecise” and clarified that he was not proposing to shut down Social Security.
AARP Report Examines Taxable Payroll Decline
A November AARP Public Policy Institute report found that wages subject to Social Security payroll taxes fell from 41% of U.S. GDP in 1983 to 34% in 2025. It estimated that maintaining the earlier share could have generated an additional $10.8 trillion in payroll tax revenue and interest through 2034, potentially extending the trust funds’ projected depletion date to 2059. Current projections put depletion in 2034, after which the program could pay about 83% of scheduled benefits.
Another proposal to address Social Security’s funding shortfall has come from Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.), who said President Donald Trump had committed to supporting his $1.5 trillion investment-fund plan. Cassidy said the proposal would invest borrowed money in the broader economy over six decades, through a fund separate from the Social Security Trust Fund, and could eventually cover up to 70% of the program’s funding needs. He also said the legislation had bipartisan support.
Disclaimer: This content was partially produced with the help of AI tools and was reviewed and published by Benzinga editors.
Image via Shutterstock
Recent Comments